Relationships between family
members can be tricky to describe in many instances, as one can see in Sylvia
Plath’s poem “Daddy”. A single event that ruins a relationship can happen, and
within the poem, the reader can sense that such might have happened, as one can
see through the speaker’s choice to call the father “bastard”. Abuse happens
that can change the attitude of the speaker’s view of the said father. Is the
death of the father in the poem “Daddy” a literal death or a figurative cry for
help towards her father in which she lost a relationship with?
Throughout
the poem, the speaker speaks of her father as if he was dead, but what if there
were another scenario that might have happened? The tone of the poem is clearly
angry but also comes across as a cry for attention that might be seen from the
view of the reader. Because many readers tend to read poems in a biographical
way, the fact that Sylvia Plath’s actual father passed away when she was young
is a good reason to assume that the father is actually dead, but stepping away
from this view, one might insinuate that the death was simply, or not so
simply, figurative. The poem suggests several instances where the speaker
reveals conflict that she had with her father. Lack of communication seemed to
be the biggest issue that the speaker had with her father, which can be seen in
the lines, “I never could talk to you./ The tongue stuck in my jaw./ It stuck
in a barb wire snare” (Plath 24-26). Lack of communication in relationships,
especially in child-parent relationships, tend to scar the children and teaches
them to fear their parent to a certain extent. Fear is a great component of the
poem because she compares her father to a Nazi, which, at the time, was rather
extreme because of how recent the Holocaust had been.
At
a point in the poem, the speaker refers to the fact that she married a man just
like her father, “I made a model of you,/ A man in black with a Meinkampf look/
And a love of the rack and the screw./ And I said I do, I do” (Plath 64-67). When
a girl marries a man who is just like her father, it is thought to be an
Elektra complex, which insinuates that she has some sort of unresolved issue
with her father. When the speaker states, “If I’ve killed one man, I’ve killed
two-/ The vampire who said he was you/ And drank my blood for a year,/ Seven
years, if you want to know./ Daddy, you can lie back now./” (Plath 68-70), is
it truly possible that she killed people? Probably not, but speaking
metaphorically, she might have cut them out of her life. This leads to the idea
that her father isn’t actually dead, but rather figuratively dead to the
speaker at the moment. This leads to another idea that quite possibly the
speaker is trying to make amends with her father, but at the end of the poem,
the speaker says, “Daddy, daddy, you bastard, I’m through” (Plath 80), offering
the idea that she has simply given up hope on redeeming the relationship that
was held between the two.
I agree with you when you said that "fear is a great component of the poem." There are many instances in the poem where she shows the fear that she had for her father. She uses images in the poem like "barb wire fence" and "Dachau, Auschwitz, Belsen." and even making the reader feel like her father was an evil man. Also, the two images I gave as an example might make the reader feel trapped, like the narrator felt towards her father. A barb wire fence is usually used to keep things inside an area, like a prison; and Dachau, Auschwitz, and Belsen are Holocaust concentration camps, where people were kept captive. All these images aren't positive images, making the reader feel afraid and fearful.
ReplyDeleteAt the end of your blog you responded to the, "Daddy, daddy, you bastard, i'm through" and you said that she has given up home between their relationship. I do agree with that, however when I read the story I was reading it as if she wrote this poem for herself, not necessarily to her father. And to me, this means that she is trying to convince herself that she has given up home for her relationship, but maybe she actually hasn't given up hope on their relationship.